Battle of the ASX retailers: should I buy Harvey Norman or JB Hi-Fi shares?

Which of these stocks is a better buy?

| More on:
Part of male mannequin dressed in casual clothes holding a sale paper shopping bag.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

The S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) is suffering a hefty bit of volatility amid a building tariff war between the US and multiple countries. Since 2 April 2025, the ASX 200 has fallen 7.5%. Could this be the right time to look at ASX retail shares like Harvey Norman Holdings Ltd (ASX: HVN) or JB Hi-Fi Ltd (ASX: JBH)?

They are two of Australia's largest retailers, selling discretionary items that Aussie households may want in their homes. The share prices of both businesses are lower, which is understandable considering a global downturn could hurt household spending.

I'm going to look at some of the factors that would help me choose between the two.

Operational differences

There are certain advantages one business has over the other, in my opinion.

I think JB Hi-Fi's earnings are more defensive than they used to be and likely more defensive than Harvey Norman because it sells a large amount of electronics that are needed by households, such as appliances, phones and computers.

Harvey Norman, on the other hand, has an impressive $4.4 billion freehold property portfolio, which is an important asset backing for Harvey Norman shares. It also has a growing presence in a number of countries outside of Australia and New Zealand, including Singapore, Slovenia, Ireland, the UK, Malaysia and Croatia. It has a total of 122 stores overseas, which generated $67.9 million of profit before tax in the first half of FY25.

Projected dividend yield

Dividends play an important role in the returns from both businesses.

Let's look at what's currently projected for both businesses, though forecasts could change if the tariff situation worsens.

According to the projection on Commsec, the Harvey Norman grossed-up dividend yield for FY25 is forecast to be 8.7%, including franking credits.

For JB Hi-Fi, the grossed-up dividend yield is forecast to be 4.4%, including franking credits, in FY25.

ASX retailer valuations

The final, and perhaps most important, aspect to consider is the valuation of both businesses.

If one has a much more appealing price/earnings (P/E) ratio, then that could tip the scales.

According to the forecast on Commsec, the JB Hi-Fi share price is valued at 21x FY25's estimated earnings. The Harvey Norman share price is valued at 13x FY25's estimated earnings.

From these numbers, I think Harvey Norman is the clear winner. It has a much lower valuation, a much higher dividend yield, international growth and a large property portfolio.

Motley Fool contributor Tristan Harrison has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has positions in and has recommended Harvey Norman. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended Jb Hi-Fi. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Retail Shares

A smiling woman at a hardware shop selects paint colours from a wall display.
Retail Shares

Wesfarmers shares recently hit a 52-week high. Can they go higher?

This business continues to impress investors.

Read more »

a jewellery store attendant stands at a cabinet displaying opulent necklaces and earrings featuring diamonds and precious stones.
Retail Shares

Would Warren Buffett buy Lovisa shares right now?

Is this a sparkly opportunity?

Read more »

Happy shopper at a clothes shop.
Earnings Results

Why did Myer shares just rocket 9%?

Investors are piling into Myer shares on Friday. But why?

Read more »

a thoughtful shopper with shopping bags wearing sparkly gold dress and matching shoes reclines on a chair with hand to chin in thought.
Retail Shares

Can Lovisa's new high profile CEO take Lovisa shares to new heights?

Is Lovisa about to embark on a new era of growth?

Read more »

A woman sits on sofa pondering a question.
Retail Shares

After soaring 244% in 5 years, how much further upside does Macquarie tip for Nick Scali shares?

The broker's expectations remain steady.

Read more »

Girl with make up and jewellery posing.
Retail Shares

Buying the dip: $5,000 invested in Lovisa shares a month ago is now worth…

It's been an outstanding first month for new Lovisa shareholders.

Read more »

Woman checking out new iPads.
Retail Shares

JB Hi-Fi share price sinks on sales growth figures

JB Hi-Fi shares are under pressure on Wednesday. But why?

Read more »

a close up of a motorcycle's front wheel and body on the open road with another motorcycle rider in the background cruising behind the leading driver.
Retail Shares

Up 100% in 11 months, can this small-cap ASX stock keep flying higher?

This business has delivered huge returns. Is it still a buy?

Read more »