How does direct indexing compare to buying ASX ETFs

Do you like index investing, but want more say in which stocks you pick?

Man smiling at a laptop because of a rising share price.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Investing using ASX exchange-traded funds (ETFs) has exploded in popularity on the Australian stock market over the past two decades or so. Using ETFs or index funds to invest has attracted thousands of investors, and billions of dollars, thanks to these instruments' low cost and simple nature.

Some of the ASX's most popular index funds and ETFs now command a huge presence on the ASX. Today, the most popular ASX ETF on the market – the Vanguard Australian Shares Index ETF (ASX: VAS) – has close to $15 billion in assets under management alone.

But ASX investors increasingly have another option to consider if they want to invest in an index – direct index investing.

When you invest in an ASX ETF or traditional index fund, you are effectively indirectly investing using a trust structure. It is the trust that owns the shares on your, and all other investors', behalf, with you being the beneficiary.

That's why ETF and index fund investors would be accustomed to seeing some fairly complex forms in their mailbox around tax time.

But direct index investing is a little different. Instead of a trust owning all of the shares in an index on your behalf, you instead own the shares directly.

According to financial advice firm Nucleus Wealth, direct index investing used to only be available for the ultra-rich. However, advances in technology have brought down the costs closer to that of an ASX ETF.

So why would one invest in direct index funds rather than ETFs? Well, there are some reasons one might prefer the direct model.

How does direct indexing compare to ASX ETFs?

For one, direct indexing enables investors to filter out any companies, perhaps tobacco stocks or mining shares, that they might not want to invest in for ethical reasons. With an ASX ETF, you pretty much have to take the entire index, warts and all.

Some ETFs do offer an ethical screen. But these can vary in what they include or exclude, and often charge users far more for the privilege.

But with direct investing, you can simply pick out the companies (or entire industries) that you don't want your money going to. Let's say you don't have a problem with uranium or tobacco shares, but you might not want to invest in coal, weapons manufacturing or oil. Well, you are free to modify your portfolio to reflect this preference. Or any other ethical bias you may possess.

You can also customise your exposure to different corners of the market. Perhaps you might like the idea of an ASX-based index fund, but you don't want a quarter of your money invested in bank stocks. Well, direct indexing lets you tweak your exposures to whatever your heart may desire.

Direct investing reportedly does still cost more than the lowest-cost ASX ETFs. According to Nucleus, fees start at around 0.5% per annum for a $10,000 investment and decrease the more cash is invested. That compares to around 0.05% for the lowest-cost ASX index funds.

But it's nice to know that there are alternatives out there for ASX investors who might not be getting all that they want out of their ASX ETF investments.

Motley Fool contributor Sebastian Bowen has positions in Vanguard Australian Shares Index ETF. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on ETFs

female real estate agent stands proudly in front of house
ETFs

Can't break into the housing market? Here's 3 REIT ASX ETFs to consider

These three thematic funds focus on real estate 

Read more »

asx shares to buy and hold represented by man happily hugging himself
ETFs

5 fantastic ASX ETFs to buy and hold forever

These funds could be destined to deliver strong returns over the next decade and beyond.

Read more »

A woman looks questioning as she puts a coin into a piggy bank.
ETFs

The pros and cons of buying iShares S&P 500 ETF (IVV) units this month

Is this a good time to invest in this leading ETF?

Read more »

Ecstatic man giving a fist pump in an office hallway.
ETFs

5 ETFs to buy with $5,000 to build a winning portfolio

Let's see why these funds could help form a strong investment portfolio.

Read more »

A graphic illustration with the words NASDAQ atop a US city and currency
ETFs

5 reasons to buy the Betashares Nasdaq 100 ETF

This fund could be well worth a spot in your investment portfolio. But why?

Read more »

A group of businesspeople clapping.
ETFs

3 reasons why the Vanguard MSCI Index International Shares ETF (VGS) is one of the best ASX ETFs

I like a lot about this fund.

Read more »

A group of young ASX investors sitting around a laptop with an older lady standing behind them explaining how investing works.
ETFs

What investors can learn from the best performing ASX ETF of FY25

Can you guess the top preforming ASX ETF of FY25?

Read more »

Two young boys sit at a desk wearing helmets with lightbulbs, indicating two ASX 200 shares that a broker has recommended as buys today
ETFs

3 things about the Vanguard Australian Shares Index ETF (VAS) every smart investor knows

There’s a lot to know about the VAS ETF.

Read more »