Better ASX bank buy: ANZ or NAB shares?

Despite overseas turbulence, Australian financial institutions have seen their valuations soar over the few months. Which one can keep it up?

| More on:
Two people comparing and analysing material.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Even though the US and Europe have seen troubles in their banking sector, the major ASX banks have been going gangbusters.

The ANZ Group Holdings Ltd (ASX: ANZ) share price, for example, has rocketed 22.5% since late March last year, and National Australia Bank Ltd (ASX: NAB) has lifted more than 27% since June.

So, right now, which is the better buy?

Let's break it down:

ANZ vs NAB shares

Firstly, let's compare the dividends.

ANZ hands out a better dividend yield of 6.4% but it is only 56% franked. While NAB shares currently pay out 5.2%, they are fully franked. 

So ultimately there is not a huge difference on that metric.

In the 2023 financial year that ended September, ANZ made $7 billion net profit on 1.7% net interest margin (NIM). NAB managed $7.4 billion on 1.5% NIM.

Again, not much in it.

What do the experts think?

According to CMC Invest, a lukewarm 6 out of 17 analysts rate NAB shares as a buy. ANZ's endorsement rate is only marginally better with 7 buy ratings from 16 analysts.

It's a tough choice.

Do you even have to buy a bank?

Perhaps the bigger question is whether it is currently worth buying bank shares at all.

The analysts at VanEck recently pointed out that "the rally in bank [stock] prices has stretched their valuations". 

"Australia's banks, when compared globally, are also the most expensive in the developed world by 12-month forward price to earnings and price to book," they said on the VanEck blog.

"While Australia's prospects for a soft landing have improved for 2024, the market seems to be pricing a dream scenario for the banks despite the risks of increased mortgage stress in a prolonged higher interest rate environment."

Also, the banking sector can be irrationally competitive.

The VanEck memo reminded investors that only a few months ago, Australian banks waged a vicious home loan price war against each other. 

This ate into their NIMs at a time when interest rates had increased 12 times in just over a year.

"Each of Australia's 'Big 4' banks face continuing headwinds in 2024. 

"A subdued economic outlook and potential RBA rate cuts could see the Big 4 banks' net interest margins continue to deteriorate."

So which is the better bank buy? 

Maybe neither.

Motley Fool contributor Tony Yoo has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Bank Shares

A man sits in contemplation on his sofa looking at his phone as though he has just heard some serious or interesting news.
Bank Shares

Here's when Westpac says the RBA will now cut interest rates

The RBA surprised everyone by keeping rates on hold last week. So, when will the next cut happen?

Read more »

Hand holding Australian dollar (AUD) bills, symbolising ex dividend day. Passive income.
Bank Shares

This is the ASX bank stock with the largest dividend yield right now

Looking to ASX bank stocks for dividend income right now?

Read more »

A man sits in deep thought with a pen held to his lips as he ponders his computer screen with a laptop open next to him on his desk in a home office environment.
Bank Shares

ASX banking sector: Is it time to consider a regional bank?

The big 4 banks are widely considered to be overvalued.

Read more »

A person leans over to whisper a secret to a colleague during a meeting.
Bank Shares

Here are the latest growth forecasts for the CBA share price

Can the bank continue rising? Here are some expert views.

Read more »

A businessman presents a company annual report in front of a group seated at a table
Bank Shares

Earnings season predictions: Macquarie weighs in on the big 4 banks

What are the broker's predictions?

Read more »

Contented looking man leans back in his chair at his desk and smiles.
Bank Shares

Major CBA investor reveals why he's all in

This investor described one major reason driving his investment in CBA shares.

Read more »

Young investor sits at desk looking happy after discovering Westpac's dividend reinvestment plan
Bank Shares

Invested $10,000 in Westpac shares 2 years ago? Guess how much you've already banked!

Atop their regular dividend payments, Westpac shares have enjoyed a strong two-year run.

Read more »

Woman calculating dividends on calculator and working on a laptop.
Bank Shares

Buying CBA stock today? Here's the dividend yield you'll get

CBA's yield right now might surprise you.

Read more »