Which had the better year in 2023: Pilbara Minerals, BHP or Fortescue shares?

We assess the performance of these popular ASX 200 mining giants.

| More on:
A group of three men in hard hats and high visibility vests stand together at a mine site while one points and the others look on with piles of dirt and mining equipment in the background.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Comparing the performance of three ASX 200 mining giants is a complicated matter, particularly when they each dig up a variety of metals and minerals and have different business growth strategies.

So, let's keep it simple and look at the metrics that matter most to ASX investors: Share price movement (capital gain or loss) and dividend payments.

On this basis, did Pilbara Minerals Ltd (ASX: PLS), BHP Group Ltd (ASX: BHP) or Fortescue Ltd (ASX: FMG) shares have a better year in 2023?

On share price movement, Fortescue shares win

As the chart below shows, Fortescue shares were superior to Pilbara Minerals shares and BHP shares for capital growth in 2023.

Created with Highcharts 11.4.3Fortescue + BHP Group + Pilbara Minerals PriceZoom1M3M6MYTD1Y5Y10YALL3 Jan 202329 Dec 2023Zoom ▾Mar '23May '23Jul '23Sep '23Nov '230www.fool.com.au

The Fortescue share price rose by 41.5% to close 2023 at $29.02. Today, Fortescue shares are changing hands for $28, up 0.9% for the day.

The BHP share price rose by 10.5% to close last year at $50.41. Today, BHP shares are selling for $48.94, up 0.58% for the day.

The Pilbara Minerals share price rose by 5.35% to close 2023 at $3.95. Today, Pilbara Minerals shares are trading for $3.86, up 1.58% for the day.

On dividend payments, BHP shares win… or do they?

In 2023, BHP shares paid an interim dividend of $1.3636 in March and a final dividend of $1.25076 in September. This totalled $2.6143 in annual dividends, fully franked.

Fortescue shares delivered a 75-cent interim dividend in March. They then paid a $1 final dividend in September for a total annual dividend of $1.75 plus full franking credits.

Pilbara Minerals shares paid a maiden dividend of 11 cents in March. The ASX lithium share paid a final dividend of 14 cents in September. That's a total annual dividend of 25 cents fully franked.

So, in dollar value terms, BHP shares win.

But what about yield terms?

Well, if we base trailing dividend yield calculations on today's share prices, Pilbara Minerals shares win.

The Pilbara Minerals dividend yield is currently 6.48%.

Fortescue shares are paying a trailing dividend yield of 6.25%.

And finally, the BHP dividend yield is currently 5.34%.

Motley Fool contributor Bronwyn Allen has positions in BHP Group. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Best Shares

A view of competitors in a running event, some wearing number bibs, line up together on a starting line looking ahead as if to start a race.
Best Shares

Best ASX 200 share of each market sector in FY25

Did you own any of these ASX 200 winners in FY25?

Read more »

Two brokers pointing and analysing a share price.
Best Shares

Best and worst performing ASX 200 sectors of FY25

The best performing sector of the ASX 200 delivered a near 25% gain over 12 months.

Read more »

Green arrow with green stock prices symbolising a rising share price.
Best Shares

Here are the 5 best ASX All Ords shares of FY25

Here are the top 5 ASX All Ords stocks for share price growth in FY25.

Read more »

A happy couple drinking red wine in a vineyard.
Best Shares

5 ASX 200 shares just upgraded to strong buy ratings

The experts say these 5 shares are set to rise over the next 12 months.

Read more »

A man sits thoughtfully on the couch with a laptop on his lap.
Best Shares

If I could only own 1 ASX stock, it would be this one

This stock offers investors a bit of everything.

Read more »

a girl stands in an apple orchard holding two red apples in raised arms with a happy, celebratory look on her face with a large smile and a pretty country background to the picture.
Best Shares

Top ASX shares to buy in March 2025

Looking to plant some new investment seeds right now?

Read more »

A woman walks along the street holding an oversized box wrapped as a gift.
Best Shares

Top ASX shares to buy following earnings surprises

Who doesn't love a surprise?

Read more »

Businessman smiles with arms outstretched after receiving good news.
Best Shares

Here are 3 of my most profitable investments in ASX shares ever (and which one I'd buy more of right now)

I reckon only one of these shares is worthy of a buy today.

Read more »