Why bother picking stocks? Why not just invest everything in index funds?

Professionals and amateur investors alike have trouble beating the market. So why is anyone putting together their own portfolio?

Woman looking at a phone with stock market bars in the background.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

The stark reality is that even professionals, let alone average punters, have great difficulty putting together a portfolio that can perform better than a market index, such as the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO).

It's just mathematics. 

If one genius stumbled upon a formula that can win all the time, then everyone would start doing it and the whole index would be dragged up. Most people are then back to average performance.

US buy-and-hold expert Brian Feroldi mentioned how his colleague Brian Stoffel disclosed his stock portfolio on social media recently.

"Stoffel shared his portfolio with the Twitter-verse. He does this every month. He also includes his overall performance," Feroldi said to his newsletter subscribers.

"Over the past five years, he has doubled the S&P 500 Index (SP: .INX)'s returns. But when compared to the Nasdaq Composite (NASDAQ: .IXIC), it's break-even."

Of course, this provoked the Twitterati to question why he's picking individual stocks in the first place.

"That led many to (correctly) claim he could have saved himself a lot of trouble by just buying a NASDAQ index fund."

Feroldi and Stoffel actually agree with this conclusion.

Even celebrity investor Warren Buffett once agreed most punters would be better off just putting all their money into index funds.

"A low-cost index fund is the most sensible equity investment for the great majority of investors," he said.

Is making money the only objective in your investment experience?

For many investors financial performance is the biggest — if not the only — priority when investing.

And there is absolutely nothing wrong with that.

But if you crave something more out of your investing experience, perhaps index funds aren't for you.

"Picture someone you care about — a child, a friend, your spouse," said Feroldi.

"Now imagine this person has found an activity that: quenches their intrinsic curiosity, leads to a deeper understanding of the world around them, helps them connect with others who have a similar passion, is not inherently toxic or unhealthy, and makes them money."

If they were fulfilled by all of the above, would you tell them to stop doing what they're doing?

"We hope the answer is 'of course not!'. We want what's best for those we love."

Individual stock picking offers investors an experience beyond mere financial gains. So whether you choose index funds or a hand-made portfolio really depends on your personal priorities.

"If investing is stressful, boring, myopic, or… unhealthy for anyone, we heartily encourage them to simply dollar cost average into index funds. There is, truly, nothing wrong with that," said Feroldi. 

"But if you consider investing to be intellectually fulfilling — and you expand your network, mindset, and wealth along the way — then we think it can be an intrinsically worthwhile pursuit."

Motley Fool contributor Tony Yoo has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Investing Strategies

A woman presenting company news to investors looks back at the camera and smiles.
Blue Chip Shares

2 of the best ASX 200 blue chip shares to buy now

Bell Potter sees these as the creme de la creme right now.

Read more »

Person pointing at an increasing blue graph which represents a rising share price.
Growth Shares

What to buy now with the ASX at a record high

Analysts think these shares could still rise strongly from current levels.

Read more »

A couple working on a laptop laugh as they discuss their ASX share portfolio.
Dividend Investing

Here are 2 ASX income stocks with yields above 7%

These businesses are providing investors with significant income.

Read more »

Man holding fifty Australian Dollar banknote in his hands, symbolising dividends, symbolising dividends.
Dividend Investing

Want passive income? Check out these ASX dividend shares

Analysts think these shares could be perfect for passive income investors.

Read more »

A couple stares at the tv in shock, with the man holding the remote up ready to press a button.
Dividend Investing

Why Macquarie expects this high-yielding ASX All Ords stock to charge higher AND boost its dividends

Looking for a quality ASX dividend share with strong growth potential? Read on!

Read more »

A miner in a hardhat and high visibility clothing makes a thumbs up symbol.
Resources Shares

4 reasons to buy Rio Tinto shares today

A leading expert forecasts strong growth potential for Rio Tinto shares.

Read more »

Loving senior couple at the swimming pool. Senior woman sitting on the edge of the pool and giving lemonade to her husband who is swimming.
Dividend Investing

How I'd invest $50,000 in ASX dividend shares for retirement, if I had to start from scratch

Here’s how I’d start building retirement income from square one.

Read more »

A man in a suit smiles at the yellow piggy bank he holds in his hand.
Dividend Investing

Forget Westpac and buy these ASX dividend shares to buy

Analysts think that these shares would be better than the big four banks.

Read more »