Better ASX rare earths buy: Iluka or Lynas shares?

This top broker is bullish on just one of the ASX 200 rare earths duo.

| More on:
A male geologist wearing a white hardhat and orange high vis vest talks on a walkie-talkie while staring at a rock showing mineral deposits

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Key points

  • There are plenty of things Lynas Rare Earths and Iluka Resources have in common
  • Most obviously, they're both ASX 200 rare earths producers
  • But top broker Goldman Sachs only tips one a buy right now

In many ways, there are more similarities between ASX rare earths shares Lynas Rare Earths Ltd (ASX: LYC) and Iluka Resources Limited (ASX: ILU) than differences.

But if an investor was gearing up to snap up stock in just one of the critical minerals producers, which would be the better buy?

Top broker Goldman Sachs has delved into the pair and come up with a clear favourite. Let's take a look.

Lynas shares compared to Iluka stock

First, though, let's compare the ASX rare earths duo.

The companies are both mining the critical minerals in Australia.

They're also both at home on the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) – Lynas has a market capitalisation of $7.15 billion, while that of Iluka is around $4.98 billion.

Lynas boasts its Mt Weld mine and operates the largest single rare earths processing plant outside of China in Malaysia. It's also expecting feed-on at its Kalgoorlie Rare Earths Processing Facility to kick off soon.

Iluka, on the other hand, holds the world's largest zircon mine in South Australia, as well as the Cataby mining operating and a processing hub in Western Australia. It's also developing a number of resources and building a fully integrated rare earths refinery at Eneabba, 300km north of Perth.

Looking at their share prices, Lynas has notably underperformed Iluka so far this year. The former stock has traded flat year to date while the latter has lifted 24%.

Created with Highcharts 11.4.3Iluka Resources + Lynas Rare Earths Ltd PriceZoom1M3M6MYTD1Y5Y10YALL1 Jan 20239 Jun 2023Zoom ▾9 Jan23 Jan6 Feb20 Feb6 Mar20 Mar3 Apr17 Apr1 May15 May29 Maywww.fool.com.au

Over the last five years, however, Lynas shares have tripled in value while those of Iluka have 'only' doubled.

So, with all that considered, let's take a look at which ASX 200 rare earths share Goldman Sachs prefers and why.

This ASX rare earths share is the better buy: Broker

Considering the pair, the top broker has a clear favourite – Iluka. It rates the stock a buy and tips it to rise 9.5% to $12.80. The broker believed the stock was undervalued and offered attractive growth potential earlier this year.

Lynas shares, on the other hand, have been slapped with a neutral rating and a $6.90 price target – a potential 9.2% downside. The broker upped its price target on the stock last month after the Malaysian government extended the cut-off date by which the company must stop importing lanthanide concentrate into the country.  

Wondering where you should invest $1,000 right now?

When investing expert Scott Phillips has a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the flagship Motley Fool Share Advisor newsletter he has run for over ten years has provided thousands of paying members with stock picks that have doubled, tripled or even more.*

Scott just revealed what he believes could be the 'five best ASX stocks' for investors to buy right now. We believe these stocks are trading at attractive prices and Scott thinks they could be great buys right now...

See The 5 Stocks *Returns as of 9 January 2025

Motley Fool contributor Brooke Cooper has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Goldman Sachs Group. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Materials Shares

Business people standing at a mine site smiling.
Materials Shares

South32 shares higher on solid half year update

The market has responded positively to the miner's update. Let's dig deeper into it.

Read more »

a woman smiles as she checks her phone in one hand with a takeaway coffee in the other as she charges her electric vehicle at a charging station.
Materials Shares

Guess which ASX lithium stock is jumping 29% on $1.6b funding boost

Big news is getting investors excited on Monday. Let's dig deeper into what is happening.

Read more »

A woman wears sunglasses as she gazes up towards a bright sun with its rays extending to the far corners of the sky above her.
Materials Shares

1 bright Australian stock that looks set to surge in 2025 and beyond

Bell Potter believes the doom and gloom is over for this stock. Let's dig deeper into things.

Read more »

A man slumps crankily over his morning coffee as it pours with rain outside.
Materials Shares

Down 57%: The Sayona share price's horror 2024 plunge

This lithium stock had a year to forget...

Read more »

Smiling mine worker at mining site with colleagues.
Materials Shares

Should you buy Rio Tinto shares after the miner's update?

Let's see how one leading broker has responded to the miner's update.

Read more »

A man wearing a shirt, tie and hard hat sits in an office and marks dates in his diary.
Materials Shares

BHP share price higher on US$2b acquisition to support artificial intelligence market

BHP is ready to step up and help support the booming AI megatrend.

Read more »

Business people standing at a mine site smiling.
Materials Shares

Rio Tinto shares push higher on solid quarterly update

Let's see how the mining giant performed during the three months and full year.

Read more »

Image of young successful engineer, with blueprints, notepad and digital tablet, observing the project implementation on construction site and in mine.
Materials Shares

Own BHP shares? Here's your Q2 preview

What is the market expecting from the Big Australian? Let's find out.

Read more »