Should ASX 200 investors sell in May and go away?

Let's answer this age-old question once and for all.

| More on:
A young woman sits with her hand to her chin staring off to the side thinking about her investments.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

If one has been investing in ASX 200 shares for long enough, one might come across the phrase 'sell in May and go away'.

This idiom is built upon the assumption that the months that follow May are typically ones that don't bode well for ASX shares and the share market. Thus, it's best to 'sell in May', ride out the annual winter storm, and buy back in at a later date. Perhaps this was the inspiration behind Green Day's 'Wake me up when September ends'.

Well, as most of us should be aware of, it happens to be right smack bang in the middle of May right now. So should investors take the hint and sell on masse today?

This idiom has been around for a long time. So let's test it out and see if it measures up by looking at what has happened with the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) after the month of May in years gone by. Perhaps we can definitely prove if May is indeed the correct time to 'go to cash' for a while.

Should ASX 200 investors just 'sell in May and go away'?

Since May is allegedly the time to sell, we'll analyse the ASX 200's historical performance between 31 May and 30 September. That last date comes from the full expression – 'sell in May and go away, come back on St. Leger's Day'. St. Leger's Day refers to a famous horse race in England, which usually occurs at the end of every September. 

Let's kick things off. In 2022, the ASX 200 closed at 7,211.2 points on 31 May and recorded a value of 6,474.2 points on 30 September. That certainly would have been a good period to heed the creed. 

On 31 May 2021, the ASX 200 finished up at 7,161.6 points at the end of May. By the end of September, the index was at 7,332.2 points. Not quite as rewarding for the 'sell in May' crowd.

2020 saw the ASX 200 round out May at 5,755.7 points, only to rise to 5,815.9 points by 30 September. Again, not a good year to cash out of ASX 200 shares in Autumn.

Pre-COVID 2019 saw a similar result, with the ASX 200 rising from 6,396.9 points to 6,688.3 points between May and September.

Finally, let's check out 2018. So five years ago, the ASX 200 concluded May at 6,011.9 points, only to rise to 6,207.6 points by the end of September.

So we have just one May out of the past five where it was worth 'going away', and four where the adage did not live up to its promise. The results are summarised below:

YearASX 200 on 31 MayASX 200 on 30 SeptemberGain/Loss
20227,211.26,474.2(10.22%)
20217,161.67,332.22.38%
20205,755.75,815.91.05%
20196,396.96,688.34.56%
20186,011.96,207.63.26%

Foolish takeaway

Looking at the data, we can clearly see that the 'sell in May and go away' idiom is, to put it scientifically, a load of hot garbage. At least for ASX shares. The reality is that any investor who followed this 'wisdom' would have been worse off for four out of the past five years. It just goes to show that there are no easy fixes or 'get rich quick' hacks on the share market.

It will be interesting to see what this year's May to September period throws up for ASX 200 shares. But I certainly won't be selling anything on 31 May 2023.

Motley Fool contributor Sebastian Bowen has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on How to invest

Person holding Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
How to invest

How to build a $1,500 monthly income stream with ASX dividend shares

It isn't as hard as you think to build a monthly income stream on the share market.

Read more »

A smiling woman sits in a cafe reading a story on her phone about Rio Tinto and drinking a coffee with a laptop open in front of her.
How to invest

How to start your ASX share portfolio with just $1,000

Investing doesn't need to be hard. Here's an easy way to start.

Read more »

Happy young woman saving money in a piggy bank.
How to invest

How I'd invest $250,000 in Australian dividend stocks to never worry about money again

Here are a number of stocks that could be top options for income investors with money to put into the…

Read more »

Warren Buffett
How to invest

5 easy steps to invest like Warren Buffett with ASX shares

It isn't as hard as you might think to invest like the Oracle of Omaha.

Read more »

A man leaps from a stack of gold coins to the next, each one higher than the last.
How to invest

Charlie Munger's 3 brutal steps to building wealth

Munger's advice still hits home.

Read more »

Person holding Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
How to invest

Buy 3,401 BHP shares for $5,000 of passive income

Want a big income boost? Here's how to do it with this mining giant's shares.

Read more »

A young man sits at his desk with a laptop and documents with a gas heater visible behind him as though he is considering the information in front of him. about the BHP share price
How to invest

Beginner investors: Start with these 2 ASX Vanguard ETFs

No investor can go wrong with these simple ETFs...

Read more »

Hand of a woman carrying a bag of money, representing the concept of saving money or earning dividends.
How to invest

The $1,000-a-month ASX share investing plan for beginners

This is an easy way to grow your wealth over the long term.

Read more »