Are Fortescue shares a buy for income or are they a dividend trap?

Are Fortescue shares a 15.5% dividend trap right now?

| More on:
A man wearing glasses and a purple vest holds his hand to his chin and wonders

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Key points

  • Fortescue shares seemingly have a dividend yield of 15.5% on the table today
  • A market expert explains how dividend traps work 
  • Fortescue shares are going for $19.17 each, up a healthy 1.11% so far this Tuesday

When one looks at the current Fortescue Metals Group Limited (ASX: FMG) share price, one metric might immediately jump out. That would be this iron ore miner's stupendous trailing dividend yield. Today, Fortescue shares are going for $19.17 each, up a healthy 1.11% so far this Tuesday.

At this share price, Fortescue's trailing dividend yield comes in at an eye-catching 15.5%. If we consider that this trailing dividend yield is also fully franked, we must also consider that this yield grosses up to an even more ludicrous 22.14% if we include the value of this franking.

So is this really what investors can expect if they purchase Fortescue shares today? Does this make Fortescue a buy today for dividend income, or is this just a big dividend trap honeypot?

A dividend trap refers to a situation where an ASX share has a seemingly attractive trailing dividend yield. But when an investor buys the shares expecting big income, they are disappointed when the company turns around and cuts its dividend, essentially 'trapping' the investor.

So is this the case with Fortescue today?

Well, let's see what one ASX expert reckons. Michael Maughan is head of the Tyndall Australian Share Income Fund. He recently shared his views on Fortescue with Livewire.

So Maughan acknowledges that "the miners have been the biggest part of the dividend pie over the last few years" on the ASX.

He notes that the current iron ore price is lower than it has been in 2022 today, but is still very high when compared to its long-term average pricing. As such, he stated that, "We expect the iron ore miners to be good cash flow generators and big payers going forward".

But does this mean Fortescue's mid-teens dividend yield is here to stay?

Are Fortescue shares a dividend trap today?

Well, not so fast, says Maughan. Here's how he described Fortescue's future dividend prospects:

There are two types of dividend traps. There's the cyclical aspect and there's the structural aspect. The cyclical aspect is you have companies that are going through cycles, the miners are a classic example. In times when the iron ore price is high, and in times when it's lower.

If you were to value that company on last year's earnings, when the iron ore price was US$220, that might not be the best benchmark to use upon which to value the company. And that came to bite. If you go back to a period like 2016 for the miners, that's a classic example of that.

…Fortescue falls into that same bucket with miners. Yes, I would definitely not use last year's yield as a way to value the company, because a yield in the high-teens is obviously too high. So if the market we're using that yield, then the stock would be much higher.

So investors definitely shouldn't count on Fortescue's trailing dividend yield as a reason to go out and buy more Fortescue shares today, according to Maughan.

But that doesn't mean Fortescue is a dud investment by any means. Chances are the miner will continue to pay out healthy dividends as long as the iron ore price remains historically elevated.

But a 15.5% yield going forward? That might be a bridge too far.

Motley Fool contributor Sebastian Bowen has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Resources Shares

A miner holding a hard hat stands in the foreground of an open cut mine
Resources Shares

A close look at BHP shares. What is the mining giant's next move?

Let's take stock of what the experts think.

Read more »

Miner looking at a tablet.
Resources Shares

Short bets on Pilbara Minerals shares are declining. Is now the time to buy?

Could the trade be unwinding?

Read more »

two men in hard hats and high visibility jackets look together at a laptop screen that one of the men in holding at a mine site.
Resources Shares

'I hate what I have done': Mineral Resources share price down as Ellison laments actions

Managing Director Chris Ellison says he deeply regrets the impact of his 'error of judgement'.

Read more »

A man in shirt and tie uses his mobile phone under water.
Resources Shares

The Lake Resources share price is sinking yet again. Here's why

The longer-term downtrend continues.

Read more »

Miner and company person analysing results of a mining company.
Resources Shares

With a P/E ratio of 6, is the Fortescue share price a bargain?

Let’s dig into whether Fortescue shares are good value or not, in my eyes.

Read more »

A man wearing a hard hat and high visibility vest looks out over a vast plain where heavy mining equipment can be seen in the background.
Resources Shares

Down 15% this year, where's the next stop for Rio Tinto shares?

Where to next for the miner?

Read more »

Miner and company person analysing results of a mining company.
Resources Shares

Can Pilbara Minerals shares cross the $3 mark?

Lithium stocks continue to split opinion.

Read more »

Female miner smiling in front of a mining vehicle as the Pilbara Minerals share price rises
Resources Shares

'Encouraging signs' for Fortescue shares heading into 2025

This leading investment expert forecasts brighter days ahead for Fortescue shares.

Read more »