Why are ASX renewable shares struggling in 2022?

Fossil fuel prices have hit decade and even all-time highs this year.

| More on:
A boy in a green shirt holds up his hands in front of a screen full of question marks.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Key points

  • ASX renewable shares have broadly underperformed fossils fuel shares this year
  • Oil, gas, and coal have all soared to multi-year highs recently
  • Some clean energy companies may have been driven up too high last year

ASX renewable shares have been struggling so far in 2022. Particularly if you compare their performance to some of the leading ASX fossil fuel energy shares.

Now, before we continue, there's no single clear definition of what constitutes an ASX renewable share.

Traditionally, you'd expect them to belong to companies providing sustainable energy sources outside of fossil fuels. Say solar, wind, hydro, tidal, or geothermal.

But, these days, you could argue that lithium miners producing a material vital to battery power storage count among that group too. But then electric vehicles need nickel and copper too.

So, while there's merit in that argument, for the purposes of this article, we'll stick to the traditional definition of ASX renewables shares.

How have these ASX renewable shares performed in 2022?

Contact Energy Ltd (ASX: CEN) has a market cap just north of $6 billion. The New Zealand-based electricity provider operates 11 power stations and produces 80-85% of its electricity from renewable hydro and geothermal stations.

The Contact Energy share price is down around 4.3% so far in 2022.

Fellow ASX renewable share, Mercury NZ Ltd (ASX: MCY) has a market cap of just under $7.2 billion. The company generates more than 15% of New Zealand's electricity and all that electricity is now generated from renewable sources.

The Mercury NZ share price is down almost 8% year-to-date.

Then there's small-cap ASX renewable share Genex Power Ltd (ASX: GNX), with a market cap of $197 million. The Aussie-based company is focused on the generating and storing renewable energy, with various solar, hydro, and wind assets.

The Genex Power share price is down 27.5% in the New Year.

How does this compare to ASX fossil fuel shares?

While not all ASX fossil fuel focused shares have shot the lights out this year, many have rocketed higher on the back of soaring prices for everything from coal to oil to gas.

The Woodside Petroleum Ltd (ASX: WPL) share price, as one example, has soared 42% in 2022, with crude oil hitting its highest levels in 14-years following Russia's invasion of Ukraine and pre-existing supply constraints.

Yancoal Australia Ltd (ASX: YAL) has performed even better, with thermal coal prices breaking all-time highs last month. The Yancoal share price is up 61% this calendar year.

What the experts are saying

Addressing the lagging performance of many ASX renewables shares, RC Global's chief investment officer Roy Chen said (quoted by The Australian Financial Review):

It's a combination of some clean energy stocks being driven up the year before, then becoming relatively expensive, while others do have some real issues. But I see the biggest problem being too many of these ETFs, or even active managers in the space, chasing very similar companies. Then when the tide turned, investors deserted the ETFs, causing outflows.

Chen added that while many fossil fuel companies have been waiting to expand their operations, a lot of ASX renewable shares have been spending big to upscale at a time when commodity prices are soaring.

"There are some of these clean energy companies that have issued profit warning after profit warning, and warned profit margins could even turn negative because costs are becoming so much," he said.

And the outperformance advantage could lie with ASX fossil fuel shares over ASX renewables shares for some time yet.

According to an analyst at Wentworth Williamson, Martin Marais:

With geopolitical issues and an industry that is incapable of rapidly ramping up production after years of underinvestment, it is likely that the supply/demand imbalance may take many months, if not years, to fix. In our opinion, demand is unlikely to fall much while there are big supply issues in terms of new discoveries and bringing extra projects online.

At US$80 per barrel for oil and with higher gas prices, we believe that Australian oil and gas producers present good value at their current prices, and accordingly we have invested a meaningful portion of our fund into our best picks among them.

What's next for ASX renewables shares?

But don't count ASX renewables shares out just yet.

According to VanEck Australia senior associate for investments and capital markets Alice Shen (quoted by the AFR):

This trend towards clean energy stocks too will likely gain momentum as energy consumers seek substitutes for fossil fuels and the demand for renewable energy rises to meet climate change carbon emissions targets.

Clean energy assets are typically pro-cyclical and tend to overperform when the economic cycle expands and capital spending on renewable energy increases. We could therefore see clean energy companies are likely to rally in the months ahead as the world seeks cleaner and more reliable supplies of energy.

The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Energy Shares

Oil worker using a smartphone in front of an oil rig.
Energy Shares

Does Macquarie rate Woodside Energy shares a buy, hold or sell?

Let's see what the broker is saying about the energy giant.

Read more »

Coal miner standing in a coal mine.
Energy Shares

Up 62% since April, what's happening with Whitehaven shares today?

Whitehaven shares have enjoyed a strong rally since April despite weak coal prices.

Read more »

A young man punches the air in delight as he reacts to great news on his mobile phone.
Energy Shares

Why Macquarie sees Paladin Energy shares as a buy in the dip opportunity

This uranium stock could be a buy according to the broker.

Read more »

Happy man working on his laptop.
Energy Shares

Opportunity knocks: 2 ASX stocks ready to surge

Analysts expect big things from these shares.

Read more »

Two businesspeople walk in opposite directions on a staircase with arrows under their arms, one pointing up and one pointing down.
Energy Shares

3 largest ASX uranium shares move in different directions amid fresh developments

Here's what is happening with Paladin Energy, Deep Yellow, and Boss Energy shares on Thursday.

Read more »

Bored man sitting at his desk with his laptop.
Energy Shares

Guess which ASX 200 share is sinking 6% on shock CEO exit

Investors are reacting negatively to this surprise news.

Read more »

Businessman working and using Digital Tablet new business project finance investment at coffee cafe.
Energy Shares

Should you buy Paladin Energy shares after the selloff?

Let's see what Bell Potter is saying about the uranium stock.

Read more »

A smiling woman puts fuel into her car at a petrol pump.
Energy Shares

Guess which ASX 200 energy stock is leaping higher on earnings growth

Investors are sending the ASX 200 energy stock sharply higher on Wednesday.

Read more »