Why did AGL (ASX:AGL) shares smash Origin in February?

The turnaround in AGL's fortunes will be a welcome relief for shareholders.

| More on:
Man wearing green shirt and pink watch flexes his muscle. representing the strength in ASX shares at the moment

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Key points

  • The AGL share price is finally outperforming its rival and the market thanks to takeover interest
  • The shares have started the year with 18% gains after crashing over the past year
  • But how AGL transitions away from coal power will be the more important longer-term driver for its shares

The AGL Energy Limited (ASX: AGL) share price has enjoyed a reversal in fortunes recently as it outperformed the market and its key rival.

The AGL share price added 2.3% over the past month and has gained around 18% since the start of 2022.

In contrast, the Origin Energy Ltd (ASX: ORG) share price slumped around 3.5% in the past month. That takes its gains since January to a modest 2.4%.

Even the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) couldn't keep pace with the AGL share price. It's barely in the black in February and has dropped 6.5% this year.

Why the AGL share price is rebounding

The turnaround in AGL's fortunes will be a welcome relief for shareholders who have seen its shares plunge over 20% in the past year.

The recent change in sentiment is largely thanks to a takeover offer by Atlassian Co-CEO Mike Cannon-Brookes and Brookfield Asset Management.

AGL has rejected the unsolicited offer, claiming it undervalues the whole business. But some believe the company is still in play as it attempts a messy demerger.

No credible transition plan out of coal

AGL's ownership of fossil-fuel-burning power plants is one of the big reasons why the AGL share price has fallen out of favour.

There isn't a clear plan on how the power plant and energy retailer can transition to a net-zero future.

Its plan to spin off the problematic coal-fired power assets into a new listed ASX entity isn't much of a solution. Many current AGL shareholders who will get shares in "Dirty Co" through the spinoff don't want to own dying assets.

AGL share price still a hostage to low carbon future

There is also no guarantee that AGL can pull off the demerger as some shareholders think it is "value destructive".

Selling Dirty Co to a group with the resources and means to more quickly replace the coal power plants with renewables is a simpler solution for shareholders – if all parties can agree on a price.

How management navigates the transition will be a more important determiner of the longer-term performance of the AGL share price.

Origin vs AGL

Being stuck with assets is the key reason why the Origin share price has delivered superior returns over the past year or more.

Like AGL, Origin has a retail business. But unlike AGL, Origin owns LNG assets. While some might say LNG contributes to climate change, gas is still regarded as a better alternative to coal.

Motley Fool contributor Brendon Lau has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Energy Shares

A young man punches the air in delight as he reacts to great news on his mobile phone.
Energy Shares

Macquarie tips 23% upside for this ASX All Ords mining stock

Let's see why the broker thinks this stock could be a top buy.

Read more »

a group of three electricity workers stand smiling wearing hard hats and high visibility vests in front of an array of high voltage power equipment.
Energy Shares

Macquarie raises price target on Origin Energy shares

The broker just raised it's price target. Here's why.

Read more »

A smiling woman holds a Facebook like sign above her head.
Energy Shares

Bell Potter says this ASX 200 uranium stock is a top buy

Let's find out why the broker is feeling bullish on this stock.

Read more »

Worker on a laptop at an oil and gas pipeline.
Energy Shares

Boss Energy shares have surged 93% since April. Here's what Macquarie expects now

Boss Energy shares remain a favourite for ASX short sellers. Are they in a for a payday or headed for…

Read more »

A young man wearing glasses writes down his stock picks in his living room.
Energy Shares

3 reasons to buy this beaten down ASX 200 coal stock today

A leading expert forecasts a big potential rebound ahead for this quality ASX 200 coal stock.

Read more »

Female miner uses mobile phone at mine site
Energy Shares

Here are the latest growth forecasts for the Pilbara Minerals share price

Can investors charge up their returns with this ASX lithium share?

Read more »

An oil worker in front of a pumpjack using a tablet.
Energy Shares

Top 5 ASX 200 energy shares of FY25 amid a challenging year for sector

The energy sector was the weakest of the 11 market sectors in FY25.

Read more »

An oil worker on a tablet with an oil rig in the background.
Energy Shares

Buying Woodside shares? Here's the latest oil price forecast from Goldman Sachs

Here’s what Goldman Sachs is forecasting for the oil price in the year ahead.

Read more »