Crikey, I really regret holding this ASX share

Ask A Fund Manager: SG Hiscock's Rory Hunter also reveals the one stock that really let him down in the past.

| More on:
a business man in a suit holds his hand over his eyes as he bows his head in a defeated post suggesting regret and remorse.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Ask A Fund Manager

The Motley Fool chats with fund managers so that you can get an insight into how the professionals think. In this edition, SG Hiscock portfolio manager Rory Hunter recalls the faith he had in one ASX share that was never repaid.

Looking back

MF: Is there a move that you regret from the past? For example, a missed opportunity or buying a stock at the wrong timing or price.

RH: Plenty. I'd actually say the opportunities that you don't end up buying, that end up generating significant returns, are probably almost the hardest to stomach. 

We'd like to think that we manage the risk in the portfolios with positioning but, on the flip side, it's hard to stomach when you like a stock and you don't pull the trigger. All the best portfolio managers are the ones that are always ready to pull the trigger. 

But I'd say in terms of investments that I've made that have been big mistakes, possibly iSelect Ltd (ASX: ISU), which would have been about 3 or 4 years ago now. 

I remember looking at the business and seeing that there was margin compression, because their revenue was shifting away from the life insurance business, which was the highest margin segment. I was convinced that they could generate enough volume in other segments to actually still grow overall profit, despite that margin compression. 

The reality is they didn't grow volumes enough. That was one mistake. But the other mistake was that whenever you see margin compression in a business, it's very rare that you see the share price continue to perform, because investors just ascribe another multiple to the business. So it's very hard for the business to actually grow a profit and the share price to perform. 

But also, in the face of that, you get multiple compression. In the face of multiple compression, as I pointed to earlier, you've got to grow profit at an extraordinary rate, just to keep the share price at a relatively elevated level. That was a big mistake and we lost a lot of money in iSelect.

I try to make sure that when it comes to actually buying businesses, as soon as we like something, we get it worked on as quickly as possible, because speed to market is a major advantage in this space, if you've got it. And that speaks to why we don't run investment committees at SGH. Yeah, we very much think that you back the team, and you back the research and the management who are willing to do that. Speed to market is a big advantage.

MF: Especially in those smaller cap companies, it really can make a huge difference, can't it?

RH: Without a doubt. It's a thing that we love about this space, that there's so much imperfect pricing. You don't actually have to dig that far below the surface, to find it. 

There's just so many opportunities out there in that universe. Well, in the small cap space, it's almost 2,000 stocks.

Motley Fool contributor Tony Yoo has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Ask a Fund Manager

A businessman wearing a dark suit points at the camera in a gesture to represent Soul Patts encouraging AGL to give more thought to the Brookfield Consortium's takeover bid
Investing Strategies

This ASX share's halved in 5 years, but I'm still sticking with it

Ask A Fund Manager: Chester Asset Management's Rob Tucker picks the stock he'd put away in the bottom drawer for…

Read more »

Three people walk in a line with their heads obscured by dark clouds.
Investing Strategies

Bargain or value trap? Fundie rates 3 ASX 200 shares going for cheap

Ask A Fund Manager: Chester Asset Management's Rob Tucker offers his thoughts on what to do with these troubled stocks.

Read more »

A boy stands firm on a rocky cliff holding a rocket in each hand and looking up toward the sky, anticipating flying into space.
Ask a Fund Manager

Fundie loves these 2 ASX 200 shares that are 'difficult to replicate'

Ask A Fund Manager: Chester Asset Management's Rob Tucker names a pair of stocks that are the best buys right…

Read more »

A headshot of Rob Tucker with a cityscape of high rise buildings in the background..
Investing Strategies

How we beat the stock market by 7% per year: fund manager

Ask A Fund Manager: Chester Asset Management's Rob Tucker reveals the secret sauce to running his successful portfolio.

Read more »

Three boxers, two men and a woman, stand in their training wear with fists raised in a fighting stance with serious looks on their faces against a background of a boxing gym.
Ask a Fund Manager

Here's one hot, one lukewarm and one cold ASX share: fundie

Ask A Fund Manager: Capital H Management's Harley Grosser decides whether he would buy three stocks that have plunged in…

Read more »

Capital H Management founder and chief executive Harley Grosser
Small Cap Shares

This $70 million ASX company just pulled off a $40 million deal: fundie

Ask A Fund Manager: Capital H Management's Harley Grosser reveals a pair of small-cap shares ready to take a massive…

Read more »

a climber scales a sheer rock cliff face reaching out for a handhold with foreboding grey clouds gathering in the sky above him.
Investing Strategies

The one ASX share we're holding onto for dear life: experts

Ask A Fund Manager: Discovery Fund's Chris Bainbridge and Mark Devcich also explain why PE ratios are absolute rubbish for…

Read more »

Three people run in a race through deep mud and puddles of water.
Broker Notes

These 3 ASX shares just halved. I would buy one of them: experts

Ask A Fund Manager: Discovery Fund's Chris Bainbridge and Mark Devcich examine whether this trio of stocks are bargain buys…

Read more »