Are A2 Milk (ASX:A2M) shares a buy? The case for and against

Stocks for this Kiwi dairy producer have nosedived since the pandemic closed international orders, and the price is now at 2017 levels.

| More on:
dairy asx share price represented by grandfather and grandson both drinking glasses of milk

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Arguably no ASX share has been pummelled more by COVID-19 than poor A2 Milk Company Ltd (ASX: A2M).

An unexpected closure of international borders badly exposed just how reliant the New Zealand dairy business was on sales from expatriate Chinese resellers (daigou) flying back and forth.

The stock hit a closing price of $19.83 in early July 2020, but it has since tumbled almost 70% to leave shareholders fuming.

In fact, some are so angry they're launching multiple class actions against the company they own.

But now that the world is entering the post-pandemic era and the share price is at levels not seen since 2017, are A2 Milk shares a bargain buy?

Two experts offered very different takes on this dilemma:

I just bought more A2 Milk shares last week

Shaw and Partners senior investment adviser Adam Dawes reckons "the worst is over" for A2 Milk.

"We've had a couple of downgrades, we've had management change, it's ticked all the boxes on the way down. It starts to look pretty good here," he told Switzer TV Investing.

"When we do start to accept some international passengers, the daigous could potentially start coming back."

The low share price and the comeback potential could attract a takeover bid from a bigger player.

"That's what the market's waiting for. We are all hoping that this one's a takeover and that could be the catalyst for A2 Milk to start to re-rate."

Dawes certainly put his money where his mouth is.

"I'm still a buyer of A2. I bought some last week."

The Chinese market will never be the same again

Burman Invest chief investment officer Julia Lee disagrees with Dawes, recommending investors stay away from A2 Milk.

"The reason for that is the major growth engine for A2 Milk was really China," she said.

"And in China I think we have seen a fundamental shift where instead of preferring those overseas brands because of safety… we are seeing a push to domestic brands, and that seems to be working."

Lee has a soft spot for A2 Milk and wants to see it become a "buy", as her fund made great money from its growth after buying the shares at around 80 cents some years ago.

But the world has moved on.

"It's a lot harder for international brands to grow in China, especially A2 Milk, which does look like it's been losing ground," she said.

"I probably wouldn't be buying A2 Milk. I think there are better opportunities."

Motley Fool contributor Tony Yoo owns shares of A2 Milk. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended A2 Milk. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Consumer Staples & Discretionary Shares

Happy friends at a party enjoying pizza, symbolising the Domino's share price.
Broker Notes

Buy, hold, or sell Domino's Pizza shares after shock CEO exit? Here's what the experts say

The Domino's share price has been recovering after losing a quarter of its value last Wednesday.

Read more »

Photo of a happy couple with their car and car keys.
Consumer Staples & Discretionary Shares

What are Macquarie's top ASX All Ords picks in the automotive sector?

Aussie investors are becoming increasingly interested in auto stocks.

Read more »

basket of grocery items with smart phone ordering system
Consumer Staples & Discretionary Shares

Here's how Aldi plans to disrupt Coles and Woolworths with online shopping

Here’s Aldi’s latest move to try to win market share.

Read more »

Two male professional analysts discuss share price movements shown on the computer screen in front of them, with one pointing to a screen
Consumer Staples & Discretionary Shares

Broker tips 40-52% upside for these ASX consumer staples shares

This broker is tipping a big year ahead for these ASX shares.

Read more »

Happy couple doing online shopping.
Consumer Staples & Discretionary Shares

Consumer dicretionary picks: what's Macquarie's price targets for Nick Scali and Harvey Norman shares?

This broker has a clear favourite.

Read more »

Woman presenting financial report on large screen in conference room.
Consumer Staples & Discretionary Shares

Why this consumer share is up 10% on earnings guidance

This company’s shareholders have seen their holdings gain 46% in a year.

Read more »

A man and a woman line up to race through a supermarket,.
Consumer Staples & Discretionary Shares

Supermarket battle: Does Macquarie see more upside for Woolworths or Coles shares?

Which stock should investors put in their shopping basket?

Read more »

Happy couple doing online shopping.
Consumer Staples & Discretionary Shares

Furniture battle: Does Macquarie prefer Nick Scali or Temple & Webster shares?

Let's see which one the broker is recommending to clients.

Read more »