Better biotech stock: Moderna vs. BioNTech

The two companies behind the gene-based COVID vaccines are a lot different than you might think.

| More on:
man receiving covid 19 vaccine moderna biontech

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

This article was originally published on Fool.com. All figures quoted in US dollars unless otherwise stated.

At first glance, the companies may seem very similar. Not only did they develop the first two COVID vaccines authorized by the Food and Drug Administration, they used messenger RNA (mRNA). It's a set of genetic instructions that direct cells to make proteins that trigger an immune response training your body for any future encounter. The technology had never been approved for a vaccine in humans. Yet, dig a little deeper and Moderna (NASDAQ: MRNA) and BioNTech (NASDAQ: BNTX) differ in important ways. They began differently, they are managed differently, and the path they are taking post-COVID is also diverging. So which one will make a better investment? A few clues offer a possible answer.

1. Different companies from the beginning

Moderna went public in 2018 in what was to that point the largest biotech initial public offering (IPO) in history. It valued the company at $7.5 billion. To get there, it had to acquire the technology for delivering mRNA into cells via a license from a Canadian biotech. Despite a legal battle, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office upheld the intellectual property claim last year. Although Moderna says its delivery technology has advanced far beyond the one it licensed, preclinical documentation submitted by the National Institutes of Health (NIH), and the company itself, may contradict that claim. It appears to describe a mechanism directly covered by the license. The story could be an unwelcome surprise for shareholders in the future. About a year later, BioNTech had its IPO. Far from the hype surrounding Moderna, BioNTech sold fewer shares than anticipated, and did so at a lower price than it expected. At the time, the company was valued at $3.4 billion. While Moderna CEO Stéphane Bancel has been labeled as brash, aggressive, and having an ego, BioNTech 's Uğur Şahin is described as holding meetings in jeans and carrying around a bike helmet and backpack. Pfizer CEO Albert Bourla has said of him, "he's a scientist and a man of principles. I trust him 100 percent." Those are just opinions, but sometimes it's all we have as individual investors.

2. What gets prioritized gets done

Even before the SARS-CoV-2 virus was spreading around the globe, Moderna was focusing on vaccines. Bancel felt the one or two jabs for inoculation made it easier to deliver mRNA than a therapeutic. It was a business decision intended to mitigate the risk of any one failure. It's the type of calculated decision you would expect from someone who went to Harvard Business School. It turned out to be the reason the company was able to deliver a vaccine candidate so quickly. It had been working with the NIH on a drug to prevent a different coronavirus -- Middle East respiratory syndrome (MERS). It's just one of the viruses the company had been working on for years. BioNTech was much more focused. Its mission was to individualize cancer medicine. Its foray into the COVID-19 vaccine sweepstakes was an opportunistic gambit. On March 16, 2020 it announced it would initiate clinical testing on its vaccine candidate and the next day it introduced Pfizer as its partner. Aside from Comirnaty -- the name of the vaccine the partners ultimately developed -- its only non-cancer program with real progress is another venture with Pfizer. That drug is a vaccine for influenza. For most of their adult lives, Şahin and his wife -- the company's chief medical officer -- have been dedicated to research that to help defeat cancer.

3. Wall Street shows one more love

Despite the similarity in approach, Wall Street continues to value Moderna at nearly twice BioNTech. Although the latter has to share revenue with Pfizer, that doesn't account for the disparity in the sales multiple. MRNA PS Ratio Chart

MRNA PS Ratio data by YCharts

Whether it's Moderna's broad ambitions, relationship with the NIH, large pipeline, or aggressive management, Wall Street clearly sees a difference.
Metric Moderna BioNTech
Market capitalization $142.5 billion $79.5 billion
2021 estimated revenue > $19.2 billion > $14.7 billion
Estimated 2021 capacity 800 million to 1 billion doses 3 billion doses
Estimated 2022 capacity Up to 3 billion doses > 3 billion doses
Active clinical trials 14 11

Data Sources: Moderna, BioNTech.

When Pfizer recently reported earnings, it upped its guidance for 2021 Comirnaty revenue from $26 billion to $33.5 billion. That should bode well for shareholders in BioNTech when it reports earnings in August. It jives with some analysts' projections for vaccine sales of $29 billion this year -- almost twice what the company has committed to.

The tiebreaker

Both companies have done something truly remarkable by launching a vaccine within a year. Each is an innovator. And both Moderna and BioNTech are in excellent financial shape to fund the rest of their pipeline of mRNA drugs. Choosing between them is like ordering dessert -- there really isn't a wrong selection. That said, the tiebreaker for me is the owner mindset. I would rather invest in the understated focus of BioNTech and its leader than the more promotional head of Moderna. BioNTech was founded by Şahin and his wife. And despite seeing his net worth climb astronomically over the past year, he has yet to sell a share. Although Bancel might as well be a founder -- he was hired shortly after the company was created. He has taken advantage of the rising stock price in a way a founder may not have. In a report last year, it was revealed that the CEO had sold stock outside of normal processes when the company announced positive news. It netted him at least $40 million. No wrongdoing was alleged. He has every right to sell stock and diversify his net worth. It just highlights the difference between the two leaders. On some level, choosing between companies is answering the question "whom do you trust with your money?" For me, the answer is easy.

This article was originally published on Fool.com. All figures quoted in US dollars unless otherwise stated.

Jason Hawthorne owns shares of BioNTech SE. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has recommended Moderna Inc. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on International Stock News

A young entrepreneur boy catching money at his desk, indicating growth in the ASX share price or dividends
International Stock News

Why this high-flying investor is selling Tesla shares and buying this US tech stock instead

Ark Invest funds have been selling the electric vehicle maker's stock over the last few weeks and reinvesting the proceeds…

Read more »

two computer geeks sit across from each other with their laptop computers touching as they look confused and confounded by what they are seeing on their screens.
International Stock News

Is Nvidia stock heading to $175?

The bulls are lining up ahead of Nvidia's earnings report next week.

Read more »

A woman holds a bitcoin token in her hand as she smiles at the camera in the background.
International Stock News

Bitcoin keeps soaring. Could it hit $95,000 this week?

Could the current crypto rally have enough juice to push the coin above that once-inconceivable level?

Read more »

A boy in a green shirt holds up his hands in front of a screen full of question marks.
International Stock News

2 reasons to buy Nvidia shares before November 20 (and 1 reason to wait)

This top AI stock has soared nearly 200% this year!

Read more »

A group of friends push their van up the road on an Australian road.
International Stock News

Why Tesla stock just pulled back

Tesla finally hit a speed bump after a blistering post-election rally.

Read more »

Two happy excited friends in euphoria mood after winning in a bet with a smartphone in hand.
International Stock News

Why Tesla stock keeps going up

Tesla stock costs more than $1 trillion now. Is that too expensive?

Read more »

A businessman in soft-focus holds two fingers in the air in the foreground of the shot as he stands smiling in the background against a clear sky.
International Stock News

2 Numbers I'll be looking for on November 20 when Nvidia reports earnings

While many analysts and investors will be looking at revenue and profit growth, two other figures are more important to…

Read more »

A man wearing a blue jumper and a hat looks at his laptop with a distressed and fearful look on his face.
International Stock News

Magnificent Seven: Unstoppable tech stock giants or risky buys?

Did you know the "Magnificent Seven" moniker was meant as a warning, not an endorsement? Check out the risks and…

Read more »