Here's 1 stock this fundie prefers over Commonwealth Bank (ASX:CBA) shares

The Allan Gray Investment Forum held in Brisbane on Wednesday gave an alternative to Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA) shares

| More on:
Woman in mustard yellow blouse on laptop holds both hands out to either side with graphic illustration of question marks above them

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA) shares have gained plenty of attention lately, as the bank approaches the $100 mark. Big profits, translating into big dividends, ignited the recent run-up in bank shares. A rotation out of growth no doubt has also helped.

However, managing director and chief investment officer at Allan Gray, Simon Mawhinney, believes there are other opportunities out there for investors.

CBA shares fall outside sweet spot

In its first national investment forum for the year, Alan Gray kicked things off in Brisbane on Wednesday. Mawhinney shared the Allan Gray approach to investing of long-term, contrarian, and fundamental to a loaded room of eager attendees.

Sticking to the Allan Gray values, Mawhinney suggested that the Commonwealth Bank is now sitting outside the fund's 'sweet spot'. Which is to say, the bank now trades at too high of a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio for its liking.

For comparison, the rising Commonwealth Bank share price has seen its earnings multiple expand from 11.96 times nearly 10 years ago, to 25.91 times. The industry average is around 15.6 times.

Commenting on Australia's biggest bank, Mawhinney said:

I believe its earnings and returns on equity are likely to mirror the average of the other banks and suspect that investors would be better off choosing another bank to invest in rather than CBA. But I am not advocating investing in the banks either. There are a lot of other opportunities available to investors.

A potential ASX challenger to Commonwealth Bank

If the banks are not looking favourable, then what are the alternatives? Well, Simon Mawhinney offered a potential contrarian opportunity in the form of Challenger Ltd (ASX: CGF).

The fund has been adding to its position in Challenger recently, with its weighting growing to nearly 2% as of 11 May 2021. Allan Gray added heavily following the annuities company's third-quarter results, which was met with a 10% selloff.  

Mawhinney provided the following commentary on why Challenger looks attractive:

Its annuity distribution network is disrupted and rates it can afford to pay its annuitants has been negatively impacted by the low returns it is able to achieve from its investment portfolio. This is all true but viewed in isolation, is only one side of the coin.

The other side, the price you pay for Challenger, can't be ignored. In my opinion, some if not a lot of these headwinds are factored into the current share price

Mawhinney doesn't foresee an imminent reversal in the share price of the ASX's biggest bank. Though, Challenger might have less upside currently priced in, compared to the Commonwealth Bank.

Motley Fool contributor Mitchell Lawler owns shares of Commonwealth Bank of Australia. The Motley Fool Australia owns shares of and has recommended Challenger Limited. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Broker Notes

Broker Notes

Brokers name 3 ASX shares to buy today

Here's why brokers are feeling bullish about these three shares this week.

Read more »

A group of three miners in hard hats and high visibility vests confer at a rocky mining site.
Broker Notes

Up 66% in a year, just how much more upside does Macquarie tip for Perseus Mining shares?

Just how much higher might Perseus Mining shares soar? Here’s what Macquarie had to say about the ASX 200 gold…

Read more »

Rising share price chart.
Broker Notes

Why this exciting ASX 200 share could rise almost 50%

Bell Potter has good things to say about this biopharmaceutical company.

Read more »

Buy and sell written on silver cubes on a stock market chart.
Broker Notes

2 buys and 2 sells in the ASX 200 financials sector: analysts

We reveal what the experts think of these ASX 200 financial shares.

Read more »

Person pointing at an increasing blue graph which represents a rising share price.
Broker Notes

These ASX 200 shares could rise 33% to 37%

Analysts at Morgans think these shares could deliver big returns.

Read more »

Female miner in hard hat and safety vest on laptop with mining drill in background.
Broker Notes

Experts reveal 2 buys and 1 sell in the ASX 200 materials sector

And they're not all mining companies, either.

Read more »

A smiling miner wearing a high vis vest and yellow hardhat does the thumbs up in front of an open pit copper mine.
Broker Notes

Why Macquarie expects this ASX All Ords copper stock to soar 48% in a year

Macquarie forecasts another big year of gains ahead for this ASX All Ords copper stock. But why?

Read more »

Middle age caucasian man smiling confident drinking coffee at home.
Broker Notes

How much upside does Macquarie expect for Steadfast Group shares?

The broker has given its verdict on this blue chip.

Read more »