Why is everyone so bad at selling shares?

Disposing is just as important as buying. But why are both professional and retail investors so poor at it?

investor scratching head as if trying to decide whether to sell asx share price

Image source; Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

The majority of stock advice articles we read are about which shares we should or shouldn't buy.

But selling is just as critical, since that's when losses or gains are actually realised.

"Selling is as important to investing as braking is to driving," Lumenary managing director Lawrence Lam posted on Livewire.

"Yet all too often, investors only know the accelerator and gloss over the analytical framework of selling. In doing so, they give up much of the hard work they have put in to establish the buy thesis."

Lam added that selling is a difficult art that even professional investors are clumsy at.

He cited a recent University of Chicago study that showed poor selling was killing performance among institutional investors.

"So bad were the selling decisions they even failed to beat a random selling strategy," said Lam.

"These weren't retail investors. The study looked at portfolio managers with an average US$600 million size. The outcome? They still failed to outperform a simple randomised strategy."

Why is everyone so bad at selling?

The reason is that humans use what are called "heuristics" to make decisions.

These are mental shortcuts that allow us to function in a world that demands complex choices be made each and every day.

The result is that we can make decisions faster and with less stress, but the solution is not necessarily optimal.

Usually, this serves us well — like when deciding which breakfast cereal to have in the morning.

But for an activity that requires complicated analysis like deciding which shares to sell and when, heuristics can cause poor outcomes.

Lam quotes three common heuristics that cause investors to dispose of their shares poorly:

  1. Disposition effect: "a reluctance towards selling losers, and inclination to selling winners"
  2. Overconfidence: "assuming you will make the right decision to sell without any factual analysis"
  3. Narrow bracketing: "looking at decisions in isolation without consideration for the broader picture"

Lam said these cognitive biases can cause one of two outcomes.

"First, you can sell out of a great company too early," he said.

"Second, a weakness in your selling process can lead to prolonging a losing investment far too long. Our cognitive biases can shroud our judgement. We can become committed to a previous decision and fail to see how changing circumstances no longer make an investment worthy of our portfolios."

Easier said than done

Times of market crashes are especially hard on our ability to think clearly about selling shares.

Instead of judging a business on its merits, investors become price-reactionary, according to Lam.

"When you're facing a 30 to 40% drop in prices, the stomach will take over the mind. Stress sets in, sometimes even panic," he said.

"Heuristics invade the decision-making process when time is pressured. Evidence points to the most severe underperformance on sales coming after extreme price movements."

Professionals are actually more susceptible to rash sell-offs during market corrections, as they have to regularly report back performance to their clients.

"They tend to use stop-losses, automatic rebalancing to benchmark weighting, and auto profit-taking triggers to simplify sell decisions."

Lam said selling a share must always be on the basis of changes in a company's prospects.

Wondering where you should invest $1,000 right now?

When investing expert Scott Phillips has a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the flagship Motley Fool Share Advisor newsletter he has run for over ten years has provided thousands of paying members with stock picks that have doubled, tripled or even more.*

Scott just revealed what he believes could be the 'five best ASX stocks' for investors to buy right now. We believe these stocks are trading at attractive prices and Scott thinks they could be great buys right now...

See The 5 Stocks *Returns as of 30 April 2025

Motley Fool contributor Tony Yoo has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on How to invest

A sophisticated older lady with shoulder-length grey hair and glasses sits on her couch laughing while looking at her phone
How to invest

Did you buy the dip on Wesfarmers shares? You just made a motza!

Buying the dip on this ASX 200 conglomerate last month would have been a very good call.

Read more »

Warren Buffett
How to invest

What is the 'Buffett Indicator'? And what is it signalling right now?

Warren Buffett believes this tool is one of the best ways to value the market.

Read more »

person laying on a couch with a hat, symbolising passive income.
How to invest

How to invest: Why Morgan Housel says '99% of good investing is doing nothing'

Doing nothing is often the best course of action.

Read more »

Happy young woman saving money in a piggy bank.
How to invest

How to build a $100k ASX share portfolio with just $250 a month

This is the easy way to build a sizeable investment portfolio without breaking the bank.

Read more »

Man holding out Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
How to invest

Want $1,000 a month in passive income? Here's how to get there with ASX dividends

The share market is a great place to earn additional income without lifting a finger.

Read more »

Warren Buffett
How to invest

4 of my favourite Warren Buffett stock investing quotes

These are excellent lessons from the Oracle of Omaha.

Read more »

Person handing out $50 notes, symbolising ex-dividend date.
How to invest

What could $10,000 invested in ASX shares become in 10 years?

Let's run the numbers and see what is possible.

Read more »

Joyful woman at a beach on the Gold Coast with her arms spread out.
How to invest

How to bank $10,000 a year in passive income from these 3 top ASX shares

Here’s how I’d go about building a $10,000 passive income stream from these top ASX stocks.

Read more »