Is Rio Tinto (ASX:RIO) share price a better buy than BHP (ASX:BHP) share price?

ASX iron ore stocks are surging and could be heading higher. The question is whether the Rio Tinto Limited (ASX: RIO) share price or BHP Group Ltd (ASX: BHP) share price is the better buy?

| More on:

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

ASX iron ore stocks are surging and could be heading higher. The question is whether the Rio Tinto Limited (ASX: RIO) share price or BHP Group Ltd (ASX: BHP) share price is the better buy?

Australia's largest listed iron ore producers have each surged between 4% and 5% in after lunch trade as they are likely to be upgraded by analysts.

A jump in the iron ore price after Brazilian rival Vale SA downgraded its 2020 and 2021 production guidance is driving these stocks higher.

The big rally among ASX iron ore miners is largely responsible for the 0.5% increase in the S&P/ASX 200 Index (Index:^AXJO) today.

BHP share price vs. Rio Tinto share price

The best way to gain exposure to this thematic is to buy a basket of ASX iron ore stocks. But if you can't or would just like to know which side you should stand on in the BHP share price versus Rio Tinto share price debate, Citigroup may have the answer.

The broker weighed up both stocks and believes that the Rio Tinto share price is the one to back. There are two key reasons for this.

"We compare BHP and RIO on a number of measures ranging from portfolio exposure, growth pipeline, strategic direction and potential shareholder returns," said Citi.

"We found more similarities than differences – though from here the strategic direction looks very different for both."

Rio wins in ESG ranking

The strategic difference here is Rio Tinto's exposure to aluminium and BHP's leverage to oil.

Citi believes that aluminium improves Rio Tinto's green credentials. This means the RIO share price will be more appealing from an Environmental, social and governance (ESG) perspective.

Investors are focusing more on ESG as compared to the past as the impact of global warming cannot be ignored. There's also a growing body of evidence that shows ASX stocks that score higher in ESG tend to perform better over the longer-term.

BHP share price influenced by oil

"BHP's green growth option is potash but mid-term growth is driven by oil and gas with additional price leverage to coking coal," explained the broker.

"Both will face increasing scrutiny around iron ore Scope 3 CO2 emissions."

Rio Tinto generates a higher yield

But there's also a more practical reason why Citi prefers the Rio Tinto share price. Citi pointed out that production growth for both miners are modest at best.

This is in part due to scale as these giants are so big that getting any meaningful increase in production is more difficult.

Also, Citi noted that BHP's and Rio Tinto's more recent efforts to increase production have been wanting.

This is why it may be more appropriate to view these stocks are income instead of growth.

"[The] near term dividend/capital management capacity favours RIO with a CY21 dividend yield of ~8% versus BHP at ~6%," added Citi.

Motley Fool contributor Brendon Lau owns shares of BHP Billiton Limited and Rio Tinto Ltd. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Resources Shares

Image from either construction, mining or the oil industry of a friendly worker.
Resources Shares

Why did the Mineral Resources share price rip 15% higher today?

The iron ore and lithium giant was the fastest riser of the ASX 200 on Thursday.

Read more »

A man wearing a hard hat and high visibility vest looks out over a vast plain where heavy mining equipment can be seen in the background.
Resources Shares

2030 forecast: As Australia's iron ore export earnings decline, copper will rise. What does this mean for BHP shares?

BHP is expanding its iron ore and copper production.

Read more »

An engineer takes a break on a staircase and looks out over a huge open pit coal mine as the sun rises in the background.
Resources Shares

4 reasons to buy BHP shares today

A leading expert outlines four key reasons BHP shares are a buy.

Read more »

Businessman walks through exit door signalling resignation
Resources Shares

Pilbara Minerals share price drops as CFO announces resignation

It’s been a challenging few years for outgoing Pilbara Minerals CFO Luke Bortoli.

Read more »

Miner looking at a tablet.
Resources Shares

What happened with the BHP share price in May?

Did you buy BHP shares in May? Here’s how much the ASX 200 miner returned.

Read more »

Two men in hard hats and high visibility jackets look together at a laptop screen at a mine site.
Resources Shares

Should I buy Fortescue shares today?

A leading investing expert offers his verdict on the outlook for Fortescue shares.

Read more »

A female miner wearing a high vis vest and hard hard smiles and holds a clipboard while inspecting a mine site with a colleague.
Resources Shares

Is this a good time to buy BHP shares?

Should investors jump on the ASX mining shares right now?

Read more »

a miner holds his thumb up as he holds a device in his other hand.
Broker Notes

Why Macquarie expects this ASX 200 copper stock to surge 36% in a year

Macquarie forecasts some hefty gains ahead for the ASX 200 copper miner. But why?

Read more »