The Westpac Banking Corp (ASX: WBC) share price is on the tumble today.
At the time of writing, the Westpac share price is down 0.61% to $16.29 a share, after falling as low as $16 earlier in the trading day. This heavy sell-off was prompted by the revelation this morning that Westpac is looking at a monster $1.3 billion fine in a settlement with the government financial regulator AUSTRAC. As my Fool colleague James Mickeboro reported this morning, Westpac had estimated the penalty would be around $900 million (which it offered to settle at), which means the bank will now have to reevaluate its books. That's partly behind today's share price fall, in my view.
So, now Westpac shares are trading at the lowest levels we have seen for 4 months, is this ASX banking giant a buy today?
Is the Westpac share price an ASX banking buy?
On one level, Westpac shares do look cheap-ish. Westpac is currently trading on a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 12.16. That isn't as low as its sibling Australia and New Zealand Banking Group (ASX: ANZ) at 11.26, but it is much lower than National Australia Bank Ltd's (ASX: NAB) 15.28 or Commonwealth Bank of Australia's (ASX: CBA) 15.6. But then again, CBA and NAB are both paying dividends this year, whereas Westpac shareholders have had their interim dividends cancelled on them. Perhaps a December final dividend from Westpac can make up for this, but I'm not holding out much hope seeing as the bank is down $1.3 billion today.
Quite frankly, I wouldn't touch Westpac with a 10-foot pole today. I don't think I would if this bank were sitting at $12 a share.
Westpac your bags
Why? Well, firstly, I'm not too impressed with the bank's conduct. Yes, Westpac CEO Peter King has offered a full apology and stated that 'we need to do better'. Bu this is the largest fine in Australian corporate history for a reason.
Secondly, there's not much in the way of dividends coming out of this bank for a while in my view. The economy is not in good shape, credit growth is likely to remain sluggish and interest rates remain at virtually zero – all headwinds for Westpac and its ability to generate earnings from which to pay dividends.
Thirdly, Westpac has not had a good history of delivering for its shareholders in my opinion. Sure, the company had paid decent dividends for the past decade. But it has also delivered virtually nothing in terms of capital growth. Today the Westpac share price is sitting at $16.20. That's the same share price investors could have bought in back in February 2002! If you had bought Westpac shares for a child born at that time, they would have to fund their first drink in 2020 with last year's dividends.
Foolish takeaway
All in all, Westpac is not a company I would consider buying today or at any time in the foreseeable future. There are simply better options out there in my view, for both growth and income.