2 reasons why adding to superannuation isn't a good idea

I think there are at least 2 reasons why superannuation isn't a good idea.

| More on:
a woman

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Australia's superannuation system is highly respected by many countries around the world.

Getting citizens to fund their own retirement is the best way for Australia's federal budget and people's finances to remain in good shape.

Contributing 9.5% of an employee's wage into super savings is good, particularly if those people wouldn't otherwise make any other savings for their retirement. Forced savings can be a good idea. 

Superannuation is also a very good way to save for retirement for people close to retirement and for high net worth people & high income earners due to the tax savings.

But there are (at least) two reasons why I'm not adding any more to my super than I need to:

Access age

Once you've put some money into your super account, it's almost impossible to get it out until you reach retirement age.

If you want to retire at a relatively young age then arguably you want less money in your superannuation account rather than more. It just means you need to invest a lot outside your superannuation account, even if it means you're taxed a bit more.

Indeed, as the ageing demographics continue to play out, I wouldn't be surprised to see the superannuation access age increase a little – although that may be an unpopular political move. Just look how the franking credit debate went down, with a successful campaign by WAM Capital Limited's (ASX: WAM) Geoff Wilson.

Shifting requirements

Superannuation is nowhere near as attractive as it was a decade ago. It used to all be tax-free in the retirement phase, but now only a $1.6 million sum per-person is tax free.

It's hard to want to lock away thousands of dollars for decades when the rules and goalposts are always changing.

I certainly expect that in 40 years it will still be better (tax-wise) to have a $100,000 share portfolio in super rather than out of it – assuming you have a full time job – but I'm not sure it will be as attractive in the future as it has in the past.

Foolish takeaway

It's definitely worth having super and contributing 9.5% of your earnings into it, but I think it is worth thinking (with your financial adviser) about whether adding more money actually suits your life's financial goals.

Motley Fool contributor Tristan Harrison has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Personal Finance

Cubes with tax written on them on top of Australian dollar notes.
Tax

How much tax do your ASX shares pay? Why it might matter

Taxes. One of the two unavoidables in life.

Read more »

a small girl empties a piggy bank of coins onto a table while her mother looks on in the background.
Personal Finance

Relying on bank term deposits to build wealth? You need to read this

Looking to grow your net worth? Term deposits may not be the best choice.

Read more »

Elderly couple look sideways at each other in mild disagreement
Retirement

How would the proposed unrealised gains tax impact your superannuation?

If passed, the impacts could be profound for those with higher-end super balances.

Read more »

a mature but cool older woman holds a watering can and tends to a healthy green plant growing up the wall in her house.
Personal Finance

$50,000 in an offset? The hidden cost of not investing in ASX shares

Saving 7.5% using an offset is not the same as earning 7.5% on shares.

Read more »

A young woman with a ponytail stands at the crossroads, trying to choose between one way or the other.
Personal Finance

Dividends or capital gains from ASX shares: Which are better?

Should investors be more interested in one type of return over another?

Read more »

parents putting money in piggy bank for kids future
Retirement

Delayed retirement and other costs of being the Bank of Mum and Dad

A survey shows delayed retirement and lost opportunities to travel are among the costs.

Read more »

A guy wearing glasses tries to show off his muscles.
Personal Finance

5 ways ASX shares investors define financial success

What does financial success mean to you?

Read more »

A man wearing only boardshorts stretches back on a deck chair with his arms behind his head and a hat pulled down over his face amid an idyllic beach background.
Personal Finance

How I'd aim to build a $75,000 income from ASX shares and never work again!

ASX shares can be a great place to generate investment income.

Read more »