Revelling in the joy of victory… before it's snatched away

A look into the psychology of loyalty… in our sporting codes, our choice of brands, and yes, even our ASX investments.

a woman

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

It would be churlish of me to bring up Sunday night's State of Origin game.

No, really. I mean, sure, I'm a New South Welshman. And sure, we won by a near-record margin.

But, be that as it may — and it's all true — it would be churlish.

No-one likes a boastful winner.

And — and here's the rub — there's a very good chance that our success is only fleeting, at least based on the last decade's results.

The only thing Queenslanders like more than winning a State of Origin series is doing it when we Cockroaches think we might just win.

Plus — and I hardly believe it, but I'm assured it's true — apparently most of the rest of the country doesn't care.

I know. I find it hard to believe, too.

Call it jealousy. Call it a lack of understanding. Call it a crying shame. 

But, and I say again, it's true.

Somewhere, in some small corners of the country (you know, in Victoria, Tasmania, the Northern Territory as well as the South and Western states of Australia), they apparently have two figs, but wouldn't give either of them — at least as far as the great game of Rugby League is concerned.

Yes, Philistines, I know. But facts are facts.

Thankfully, most of my colleagues happen to live in Rugby League states. I don't say that as a slight on the other (lesser, by definition) states, you understand.

Just that when it comes to sport, most of the team are fans of at least one code of Rugby — making the office watercooler a more vibrant place this time of year.

Except — and here's where they really lose me — some of my fellow New South Welshmen either didn't know the game was on, or they didn't care.

One of them doesn't really 'get' sport at all.

Of course, an official warning followed, and HR will be taking further action.

In all seriousness, though, it prompted a really interesting conversation.

For those of us for whom watching or participating in sport is second nature, it can be hard to imagine just how our fellow humans couldn't possibly share our interest.

Just as it's hard for them to fathom what's going on when we yell, in an apoplectic rage, at the poor referee or umpire just trying to do their best.

As my wife will tell you, "They've been doing it all day, sir" is a common refrain — and not only when I'm at the game. How it's possible that the referee can't hear me through the telly is something modern science is yet to resolve.

And yet, my reality is my reality, just as my non-sports-obsessed colleagues' is theirs. Yes, even AFL fans have their own reality (though St Kilda supporters, I'm quietly informed, don't always share the same reality as the other AFL fans. I pass that on merely as information; I'll leave that to you Southerners to resolve one way or the other.)

What's the difference?

Biology? Maybe.

Environment? Possibly.

Experience? Potentially.

My young bloke is a fourth generation Sydney Roosters fan, despite none of the family living in the Eastern Suburbs for the best part of half a century.

He's pretty much inherited the team. I'm pretty sure he's absorbed the interest in sport from those around him. And yes, humans have gathered to watch gladiators fight for centuries.

(No, not that Gladiators. Not the one You know, the one with Mike Whitney as the black-and-white-outfitted referee. You know, the Russell Crowe kind. Anyway, I digress…)

Thankfully, I'm a better investor and advisor than I am an evolutionary biologist.

But — while we can use sporting analogies a little too often when it comes to business and investing — the whole State of Origin thing is worth considering, especially when you're investing.

Coca-Cola drinkers are something of a tribe, aren't they?

So are the wearers of this season's coolest sneakers. And the 'tweens who shop for stationery at Smiggle. 

Brand loyalty, especially these days when you don't have to worry about being poisoned by unbranded food, is almost completely irrational. That's not a criticism, by the way.

Or, if it is, I'm guilty of it, too.

Think about the Apple fans. Is there a more diehard group on the planet? They'd put Queenslanders in the shade for pure passion.

You don't have to be an Apple fan to recognise the company's pull. Or to love soft drinks to know that the red and white can is worth at least double the price of a homebrand cola in most people's eyes. 

And here's the thing — every fan is completely able to rationalise their passion. 

"Coke tastes better. That's why it's worth paying double for"

"Mercedes makes better cars. Of course they're worth 5 times the price of a Kia"

"Apple products look better. Feel better. They just work"

Are those people wrong? No. At least, not in their own eyes.

And in our eyes? Who are we to say our judgement is superior to theirs? I mean, we all intrinsically believe it — or we'd change our minds!

But rationally, we need to accept that our beliefs — like theirs — are the combination of prejudices, experiences, preconceptions and emotions… most of them invisible to our conscious minds.

They're the building blocks of our decision-making. The sports and teams we support, the way we shop and, yes, how we invest.

Let me give you a few recent things that 'everyone knows' by way of example. How about:

"No-one drinks Coke any more" (Sales might be flat, but Coke still sells truckloads of the black fizzy stuff)

Or

"We're all eating more healthily" (Really? Have you seen Macca's sales growth?)

What about

"The internet is going to kill Flight Centre" (that one has been doing the rounds for two decades)

I had a mate who would never invest in beer companies back in the day because 'the beer is terrible'. Maybe it was, but hundreds of thousands of us drank it each week.

As Mark Twain (is misquoted as having) said:

"It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so."

Is the economy really going into recession?

Are ASX tech stocks worth more than 100 times earnings?

Should you really be paying more than 20 times earnings for a supermarket chain with anaemic growth?

The answer is an emphatic 'maybe'. 

Just like the chances of NSW taking out a State of Origin series.

And St Kilda winning the flag.

I just don't know which will happen first.

Fool on!

Motley Fool contributor Scott Phillips has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Motley Fool Take Stock

a group of people stand examining a large glowing cystral ball held in the hands of one of the group members while the others regard it with various expressions of wonder, curiousity and scepticism.
Motley Fool Take Stock

Here come the 2025 predictions

What might or might not happen over the time it takes for the Earth to make one trip around the…

Read more »

family taking gear out of back of car for camping
Motley Fool Take Stock

Getting the balance right

18 summers fly by quickly.

Read more »

a group of people in shadow profile leap and hold their arms high in wonder of a fireworks display that fills the sky with light and colour and spectacular shapes.
Motley Fool Take Stock

Looking for New Year's resolutions you can keep?

Celebrate progress, not perfection.

Read more »

Six young people wearing Santa hats sit on a beach celebrating at sunset.
Motley Fool Take Stock

Merry Christmas, from The Motley Fool

And a Foolish Christmas Carol.

Read more »

santa looks intently at his mobile phone with gloved finger raised and christmas tree in the background.
Motley Fool Take Stock

Not so fast, Santa. We need to talk

Before the good times carry you away...

Read more »

Woman with a moving box on her head.
Motley Fool Take Stock

A 40-year mortgage? No thanks.

A great way to make housing less affordable.

Read more »

Bitcoin ticker on a blue and black sphere.
Motley Fool Take Stock

No, you're not wrong about Bitcoin… yet, at least

Three weeks does not an investment thesis make...

Read more »

Gold piggy bank on top of Australian notes.
Motley Fool Take Stock

No, Treasurer. Leave the Future Fund alone

They just can't leave well enough alone...

Read more »